Web-Based Digital Health Interventions for Weight Loss and Lifestyle Habit Changes in Overweight and Obese Adults: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

 

Our purpose turn out to be to conduct a scientific examine and meta-evaluation of randomized controlled trials to research the effect of Web-based digital ...

This systematic review evaluate the efficacy of eHealth weight control interventions amongst obese and overweight racial/ethnic alternative ...

Literature assessment findings summarising virtual health interventions geared toward treating or dealing with weight troubles, high blood stress, or type 2 diabetes.@  Raed More  theslashgear

Bookmarks

Review

1Internal Medicine Department, Faculty of Medicine, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil

2Department of Medicine, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia

3Flinders Digital Health Research Centre, College of Nursing and Health Sciences, Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia

4Quality Use of Medicines and Pharmacy Research Center, School of Pharmacy and Medical Sciences, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia

5Telehealth Center, Hospital das Clinicas, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil

Corresponding Author:

Alline M Beleigoli, MD, PhD

Internal Medicine Department

Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais

Avenida Professor Alfredo Balena

Abstract

Background: Obesity is a relatively time-honored circumstance with critical health implications. Face-to-face interventions to treat weight issues demand a huge form of human belongings and time, producing a outstanding burden to humans and health machine. In this context, the net is an attractive device for handing over weight reduction program due to mystery, 24-hour-accessibility, scalability, and reachability associated with Web-based totally programs.

Objective: We aimed to analyze the success of Web-based totally virtual fitness interventions, besides hybrid interventions and non-Web-based generation inclusive of text messaging, quick message company, in evaluation to nontechnology energetic or inactive (wait listing) interventions on weight reduction and way of life dependancy modifications in people with overweight and weight problems.

for randomized trials that in comparison Web-based digital fitness interventions to offline interventions. Anthropometric changes which embody weight, frame mass index (BMI), waist, and body fats and manner of lifestyles addiction changes in adults with obese and weight troubles were the consequences of interest. Random outcomes meta-evaluation and meta-regression had been executed for imply variations (MDs) in weight. We rated the hazard of bias for each have a look at and the terrific of evidence across studies the usage of the Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation method.@  Raed More  onlinedigitaltrends

Results: Among the 4071 articles retrieved, eleven were protected. Weight (MD −zero.Seventy seven kg, ninety 5% CI −2.Sixteen to zero.Sixty two; 1497 individuals; moderate certainty evidence) and BMI (MD −0.12 kg/m2; ninety five% CI −zero.Sixty four to zero.Forty one; 1244 participants; moderate fact proof) modifications have been not wonderful amongst Web-primarily based definitely and offline interventions. Compared to offline interventions, virtual interventions brought about a greater short-time period (<6 months study-up) weight loss (MD −2.Thirteen kg, 90 five% CI −2.Seventy one to −1.Fifty five; 393 participants; immoderate reality proof), but not inside the long-term (MD −zero.17 kg, ninety five% CI −2.10 to as a minimum one.Seventy six; 1104 members; moderate fact proof). Meta-evaluation have become not viable for way of existence addiction modifications. High chance of attrition bias end up diagnosed in 5 studies. For weight and BMI consequences, the knowledge of evidence changed into mild specifically because of excessive heterogeneity, which end up specifically attributable to govern group differences at some stage in studies (R2=seventy nine%).

Conclusions: Web-based virtual interventions introduced approximately extra short-time period however no longer lengthy-time period weight reduction than offline interventions in obese and overweight adults. Heterogeneity became excessive at some stage in studies, and immoderate attrition costs suggested that engagement is a awesome difficulty in Web-based totally totally interventions.

Keywords

Introduction

Facing the global weight problems epidemic is a number one public health project . The occurrence of weight problems has nearly doubled over the past 30 years , musculoskeletal problems, highbrow stress, and high-quality forms of maximum cancers. All the ones morbidities appreciably increase mortality and decrease notable of lifestyles .

Obesity remedy consists of a systemic method with both person and environmental strategies . The man or woman interventions are normally introduced face-to-face, which generate immoderate desires for humans, due to their extended route, and a first rate burden to the fitness care device due to the high incidence of weight issues . Despite such efforts, the effectiveness of weight troubles interventions on weight reduction is extremely good modest, specifically inside the long-time period .

In this context, Web-primarily based digital generation can be a specifically exciting tool for the remedy of obese and weight issues due to its capacity for achieving a large amount of humans even in faraway regions on a 24-hour in line with 7-day routine. Delivering weight loss interventions at the Web permits centered on a larger wide variety of people compared to stand-to-face interventions and is probably a great deal less time ingesting and further charge-effective for specialists and patients . Previous evaluations have verified a modest superiority of virtual interventions in assessment to offline interventions near weight reduction [,]. However, as those critiques covered studies that investigated hybrid interventions both in the intervention (eg, Web-primarily based totally plus brief message organisation text messages) and manage groups (ie, face-to-face plus generation-primarily based interventions), the effect of interventions that use handiest Web-based totally transport isn't regarded.

Our intention changed into to behavior a systematic assessment and meta-evaluation of randomized managed trials to investigate the impact of Web-based totally virtual interventions in contrast to real-international interventions on anthropometric measures and changes in dietary and bodily interest conduct in individuals with overweight and weight troubles.

Methods

Systematic ReviewStudies were eligible within the event that they noted records on randomized managed trials, which recruited adults (≥18 years) with overweight and weight troubles (body mass index [BMI] ≥25 kg/m2) right right into a Web-primarily based completely definitely digital intervention (accessed via browser or Web-based totally software program, irrespective of tool) in preference to offline or in-person (face-to-face) interventions. Studies that did now not exercise any lively interventions (wait listing) inside the manipulate corporation were additionally blanketed. Exclusion criteria comprised research wherein overweight and weight issues have been not a number one preference criterion or the ones wherein the predefined consequences have been no longer stated. Additionally, studies that protected kids, more youthful humans, or pregnant women have been excluded. Trials of hybrid interventions (Web-based virtual interventions plus face-to-face interventions or unique generation-primarily based interventions, together with mobile brief message carrier text messages or digital intervention plus offline interventions) and those that blanketed virtual interventions inside the manipulate company had been additionally excluded. Moreover, research comparing the prevention of weight regain after a previous intervention and people that did not record the predefined outcomes of hobby have been not covered. Multiple opinions from the same examine were taken into consideration as a unmarried one. We taken into consideration modifications in anthropometric measures and in nutritional and bodily interest behavior because the consequences of concentration.@  Raed More  fitfulliving

Two reviewers (AGC and MNLP) by yourself carried out the choice of the research regular with the predefined eligibility standards. Any battle of phrases amongst them have become evaluated through 2 exclusive authors (AMB and AQA). AMB and AQA independently extracted statistics from reviews based totally on a predefined information extraction form. Any confrontation amongst them have become evaluated via both MdFHD or ALR. When some information changed into not smooth within the document, authors had been contacted thru e mail. Hand are seeking became completed within the references of previously published critiques.

Quality of the Evidence

We used the Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) technique to evaluate the extraordinary of evidence retrieved through the systematic observe. This consists of comparing the threat of preference (randomization and allocation), overall overall performance (blinding of people and employees), detection (blinding of final effects assessment), attrition (incomplete very last outcomes facts), and reporting (selective reporting) bias of man or woman research. In addition, the GRADE method indicates assessment of indirectness, inconsistency, imprecision and ebook bias of the evidence commonplace so one can grade the volume of the proof retrieved.

Meta-Analysis

We used a random results version to calculate precis advocate variations (MDs) and ninety 5% CIs for 1 unit trade in weight (kg), BMI (kg/m2), waist (cm), or body fats (%). In instances wherein every “in step with protocol” and reason-to-cope with outcomes have been furnished, the latter had been used to calculate summary MDs. For nutritional and physical interest behavior, we observed a terrific variety inside the devices used to diploma modifications a number of the companies. This finding precluded meta-evaluation, and we completed satisfactory qualitative assessment of these consequences. We used the Cochrane Review Manager software software program for the ones analyses .

A random effects meta-regression model modified into used to decide whether or not or no longer the form of manage enterprise (with and with out active intervention) became a supply of heterogeneity among research. We completed sensitivity analyses in step with the period of observe-up (<6 and ≥6 months) and the type of manipulate intervention (presence or no longer of a nondigital intervention within the control group). We used Comprehensive Meta-Analysis software program application software model three for this analysis .

Results

Systematic Review

The are in search of approach brought about 4071 articles. After exclusions, as validated in , a entire of eleven research [-] that analyzed statistics from 1525 participants had been retrieved. Female sex have emerge as essential in most of the studies. The age of the individuals severa from 18 to sixty five years. Most of the research excluded contributors with comorbidities and pregnancy as well as human beings who have been engaged in precise weight reduction applications. Unhealthy manner of existence behavior were now not an inclusion standard in any of the retrieved studies. Recruitment settings numerous a number of the studies and guarded community populations, experimental medical doctor-referred patients, organization personnel, and university college students or group of workers. Other inclinations of the research retrieved are depicted in .

Interventions have been predominantly delivered through internet browsers, besides 2 that were added through manner of a smartphone app [,]. Diverse behavioral techniques, such as cause putting, self-tracking and control, social useful resource, modeling, and remarks have been applied inside the studies. The control companies obtained both no intervention (wait listing) or fashionable face-to-face interventions ().@  Raed More  webdigitaltrends